Sunday, February 1, 2009

"What millions died--that Caesar might be great!"

A student from Sea Cliff High School's class of '57, Wallace Kaufman, has gotten in touch with me through an e-mail. Wallace informed me that he was doing a history of his class, and asked if I would respond to some questions. Of course I told him that I would be delighted to answer some questions as long as they were not too difficult. I imagined that he would want to inform members of his graduating class that Dr. Ross was still alive, living in Florida and spending his hours writing gazillions of blogs once I found out what they were. I did send him an attachment of a Boca Raton News article that spoke of the military awards I received belatedly from the Navy...mainly the 10 Air Medals and the two Distinguished Flying Crosses. Part of his response follows:
"Thanks, Doc. I will make good use of the article. And congratulations. We are both old enough now to be frank. First, I admit that I'm given too excess sentimentality at times. Which leads to the next sentiment--that I am sad that we knew nothing of your pre-Sea Cliff life when you stormed into Sea Cliff School and became part of it in the mid 50s. One class member I sent to your blog has asked why not, why didn't we know? Some reasons are obvious, but the fact is we knew almost nothing about any of our teacher's prior lives or personal lives other than where they went to college. Was it school policy that there be a wall between students and teachers' personal lives? ... I know that many veterans feel it is akin to boasting to talk of their service, and others would rather not remember the dangers, the fears, the others who suffered and died. In any case, knowing more about the service given by our teachers might have had some small but important influence on our understanding of military service as well as the character of our teachers. Whatever the case, a very belated and sincere thanks for what you did."
Now, I will not speak for every veteran or teacher, but I think it was a mistake not to discuss the war experience with our classes. Out of such discussions I believe would have come more first hand knowledge of what the war was like and about, accompanied by more respect for the teacher. I don't believe a veteran's discussing his experience would be boasting; and I'm sure it was not the reason for failure to communicate that experience to the kids. I think Wallace was right when he said perhaps it was the case that their teacher would rather not remember his (or her) fears and horrors by dredging it up in the classroom. In my own case, the war was still too close in my memory. I tried with great difficulty to forget it and to press on with my life. My brain was still littered with scorpions...and to this day I still mourn for my buddies who did not return. This failure to reveal one's war experiences in the classroom was not due to any "school policy" nor was there any real "wall". It was just the way it was and will always be.

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

I don't know if I agree with your final comment. Many social mores have changed, even from the days I was in school to nowadays.

There was a distance and a different kind of respect for teachers and other adults in positions of authority "back in the day." I'm going to take a stab at it, and say it began to change in the tumultuous '60s.

Today, there is a more relaxed, almost "chummy" sort of relationship. One can argue whether it was better back then than it is now.

Certainly there can tend to be problems when teachers become buddies or friends. On the other hand, too much distance can make students feel they have nothing in common with their teachers and therefore nothing to learn. The good teacher will strike the right balance (I believe Doc and Phil B did).

That said, I think there will always be some teachers who will share their former lives and accomplishments, and there will be some who don't. And there will always be some students who care to know and those who don't.

Oh, I guess, Red Baron, I've come full circle now to agreeing with your last assertion: It is the way it is and always will be. LOL.

Wallace Kaufman said...

Thanks for the notes on what students didn't know and teachers didn't tell about the lives of teachers. If I could institute a requirement on this subject it would be that each teacher create an autobiography that might be opened on his or her retirement or death.

More useful to present students would be a judicious and formal CV. I say formal because a set format would not invite showmanship, give the appearance of boasting, or exhibitionism.

I suspect such knowledge might lead to some unfortunate nicknames and such, but on balance, I think they would be a reasonable way to inform students without compromising teachers.

Your blog, Doc, is welcome and still useful, at least for those of us who are still learning.
Best,
Wallace

Wallace Kaufman said...

PS. Editorial correction: I and my classmates graduated in 1957, not from North Shore but from Sea Cliff. We were the last class of seniors out those double doors.
Wallace

Mike Herbstman said...

Excuse me, bu I googled "happy asses", and it direced me to this site. Please send prices and descriptions. Thank you

Anonymous said...

I am privileged to lend a comment or two as, Jim Morrison once said: 'There are things known, and there are things unknown and in between is, the door - I wanna be that door'. Doc, ok, Red Baron/Norman/Rosie, (choose your identifier here) has been many things to many people and this is my point. I hadn't a clue about this man until he sent me his book, "Memoirs of a Tailgunner". Fascinating this opening of doors, and to his faithful I add the following comment I wrote when petitioned to send in a tribute on the honoring of "Doc" a few years back. Doc/Coach: "He had an aura about him...one of those intangible talents rarely found by youths desperately seeking someone to motivate them to their full potential. Doc was a master of athletic psychology - knowing which secretive button to push...selectively unleashing our individual maximums through just the right words, spoken in timely conspiracy against the limits we thought we had already reached. And he knew precisely when to turn it off - when to deny us the acceptance we were looking for in him so that we would elevate our achievement to the next level if for anything, just to please him". "Go know"! Ok, just this once, "Flash"